Interesting, to me, are tyer perspectives on craft fur. I'm a believer that tyers eventually get comfortable with whatever they work with most often. I started off tying with cards of Westrim Craft Fur. It was 3-in. long pile fur with very short underfur. Seems good doesn't it? Its problem, to me, was that it took several cuts and stacking to provide enough fur for small 1/8 and 1/16 jigs. So, I used it up very quickly. I don't believe that Westrim sells any of it anymore, though I doubt that's due to lack of sales to fly and jig tyers.
Darice was next up. Underfur is inherent with it, but that's why I forced myself to thin and trim it wisely. I've since developed my technique to working with it. So, now I feel like it's up to the other furs to impress me or change my mind about it. The negative to Darice, as AF points out, is their lack of colors beyond the basics. Do wish they'd sell chartreuse or olive as I'd try to be one of the first in line to buy it.
Have moved on since to some others. Orvis Polar Fiber is very good. Like most, it has underfur to thin. Its unit cost is more expensive than most other synthetic furs. I like Targus Foxxfur a lot, but it's also relatively expensive. It has underfur that falls out like dandruff when cut
, but I like it nonetheless. I tried Hareline Dubbin's Extra Select Craft Fur during a tying class and noted its similarity to some long pile craft furs I've seen on bolts sold at fabric stores. It's fine, but I've had to remove quite a bit of underfur from it to satisfy a tie. However, in another instance, I was advised to keep much of the underfur to bulk up the size of the fly that I was tying. So, it can be six on one hand and a half-dozen on the other regarding craft fur and its underfur. :huh:
I like buying good craft fur off of bolts when I find them at a fabric store. Much of my fun comes from hunting it down. There's something different to be seen at nearly every store. I believe that I own sage-colored craft fur from a bolt that, for whatever reason, facilitates tying small jigs that catch fish quite well. It has underfur, but I continue to work with it the very same way I do with Darice long pile.
Troll doll hair is good to use. If you're comfortable working with Darice craft fur, then try it some time.
I've acquired some old-looking cards of Fibre-Craft Craft Fur swatches recently. Looks great for small jigs. Bet you it's no longer made.